Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility

Straub Insurance Agency

The Right Insurance For All Of Your Needs

Your Local Agent

Serving All Of Your Insurance Needs Since 1959

Need Insurance?

Get The Right Insurance, At The Right Price

We provide comprehensive insurance policies with the right coverage at a price that fits your budget.

auto insurance st. marys PA 15857

Auto Insurance

Next to your home, your automobile is often the most expensive piece of property you own. As a result, it is important to seek the best value when buying your insurance.

business insurance st. marys pa 15857

Business Insurance

We know how hard you work to cultivate and maintain your business. We also know there are risks you face every day that threaten what you’ve built. We put that knowledge to work by offering products and liability coverage to soundly protect you and your business.

homeowners insurance st. marys pa 15857

Home and Property

When most people hear the word ‘insurance’ they think of their cars, but in many cases their home is the most important and expensive piece of property they own.

life insurance st. marys pa 15857

Life Insurance

Life insurance provides cash for your family in the event of your death to ensure that they can remain in their home and continue to maintain an adequate standard of living.

health insurance st. marys pa 15857

Health Insurance

Insurance for those under 65 years of age, Medicare supplements, Medicare Part D and Medicare Advantage insurance.

insurance services st. marys pa 15957

Client Services

Make an insurance payment or file a claim the easy way – online. It’s convenient and these services are available 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. 

What We Do

Helping You With All Of Your Insurance Needs

Erie Insurance in St. Marys PA 15857



We’re An Independant Insurance Agency Representing Erie Insurance

Our experts are waiting for you!

Straub Insurance Agency and Erie Insurance are committed to maintaining a high standard of excellence and establishing a strong relationship of mutual trust and service to each of our clients.

We offer personal attention, full-time professional service, competitive pricing, a broad range of insurance products to meet your needs and an experienced staff of conscientious professionals.


Auto Insurance

Discover car insurance that fits the way you want to live.

Business Umbrella

Umbrella coverage gives extra liability coverage for your business.

Whole Life Insurance

Affordable whole life Policies tailored to your needs.

Motorcycle Insurance

We've revved up our motorcycle coverage and our prices, too.

Homeowners Insurance

It's your home — find out how we can help you protect it.

Universal Life Insurance

Universal is a type of life insurance that lasts your entire life.

RV Insurance

Keep the camping fun and safe by protecting your RV.


Renters Insurance

What about protecting all your stuff in your new space? We can help.


Purchase an annuity to help grow or protect your retirement savings.


Boat Insurance

Make sure your boat is covered from bow to stern with boat insurance.

Mobile Home Insurance

When something unexpected happens, our insurance can help cover the losses.

Long-Term Care

Most of us will need long-term care at some point in our lives.


Classic Car Insurance

Classic cars can be added easily to your auto policy.


Valuables Insurance

Insurance coverage for your most valuable personal items.

Individual Under 65

Under the age of 65 and need health coverage for you or your family?

Business Insurance

You've worked hard to build and grow your business – help keep it safe.

Flood Insurance

Floods can happen anywhere it rains. Are you covered?

Medicare Supplement

Select the best supplement insurance for your needs and budget.


Business Auto Insurance

Having commercial auto coverage you can truly count on essential.

Home & Property Umbrella

Umbrella insurance provides coverage beyond your renter's policy.


Medicare Part D

We'll help you get the right Medicare drug plan for you.


Workers Compensation

With a workers' compensation policy we'll be there when you need us.

Term Life Insurance

Protect your family with affordable and flexible life insurance coverage.


Medicare Advantage

Medicare Advantage Plans provide all your Part A and Part B benefits.

Get it Today!

Request A Quote


See what some of our long-time clients have to say abou the service they receive from Straub Insurance Agency - your local Erie Insurance Agency.

Straub Insurance


"Their follow up service has been great..."

I recently switched my home, auto and business insurance to Straub insurance. The agent invited me to their office and explained all the fine print in the policies. It took some time, but they made sure all my questions were answered. Their follow up service has been great too. They are always available by a phone call, text, or email.
Straub Insurance

TJ and Ashley

"...would not change a thing!"

We switched to Straub Insurance a few years ago and would not change a thing! They are always so upfront and honest and so helpful whenever we have a question. They have been excellent at anticipating what types of coverages we needed and helped us to make decisions and changes to best fit our current situation.

Latest News

Get The Latest Updates On All Our Insurance Products

How to Find Good Cheap Car Insurance

How to Find Good Cheap Car Insurance

Whether shopping for electronics, furniture or a new car, we all love getting the most bang for our buck. The same is true for cheap car insurance. Insurance companies know...

read more

Over 60 Years Experience

We are Proud to Represent These Insurance Companies

Millville Mutal Insurance Agent
progressive insurance agent st. marys pa 15857
foremost insurance agent st. marys pa 15857
AIC Insurance logo
american collectors insurance st. marys pa 15857